Hi SNEVEDS,
Sorry that the steps in this guide weren't helpful in getting your game up and running. I certainly sense your frustration and empathize. I will try and address your questions as best I can.
1) Why would a company release an 'expansion pack' to base software that requires anyone to go through such extreme efforts just to be able to even load the game--shouldn't the software be made to self configure properly 'out of the box'?
The short answer is
yes.
Ideally developers have a responsibility to insure that their products are as "dummy proof" as possible right out of the box.
Looking at it objectively however it seems pretty evident that the Sims series offers several additional QA challenges not necessarily present in other titles.
The sheer size of the game, the endless variations of user configurations and the complexity of the coding make The Sims more of a QA challenge than most titles right out of the gate. Toss in the
"X" factor of user created content and it becomes even
more daunting to assure that the expansions will just "plug n' play" flawlessly on top of the original code.
2) Why would anyone want to risk loading such damaging software if warned in advance--should there be a sticker on the box saying something akin to "Caution--special instructions are required just to load this software and after even a proper loading please be aware that this software may very likely still not run properly"?
I'm not sure what you are referring to when you say "damaging software".
I'm going to take a shot in the dark here and guess you are referring to the software programs I recommended in the OP.
The programs I recommended have been around for a long time and have been recommended many times in other help/troubleshooting threads.
However as highly regarded as those programs are, there is
always the possibility of user error and/or that using these programs could produce undesirable results. Hence the disclaimer.
3) Because Sims 2 loaded properly as did all of its expansion packs without a major hitch--is it too much to expect that Sims 3 should work similarly?
No not at all. From a consumers point of view I would certainly expect that when I buy something it's going to work as intended.
However there is a bit of a problem with your statement.
That being it implies that the game didn't load correctly out of the box for
anyone which is simply untrue. This is an important troubleshooting distinction because what it
proves beyond a
reasonable doubt is that the problem doesn't lie with the coding
per-se, rather (more likely) with the
compatibility of that coding with unknown or unanticipated variables.
Another very important thing to keep in mind is that the overwhelming majority of people using 3rd party CC are also using a third party installer which is definitely causing installation issues. I've experienced this myself.
As far as I know there weren't such problems with any of the auto-CC installers for TS2.
There isn't really anything extraordinary in the steps I have outlined in the OP.
At the very
least they are basic maintenance tips that should be practiced by all PC users as GP, and at
most they are additional steps that should be taken whenever loading a program of such massive size and complexity.
4) Sims 3 & expansions cost 25% more--shouldn't they run at least 25% or more of the time?
I'm going to go ahead and chalk this statement up to frustration and assume it was rhetorical. ..again I
really do empathize....with your plight.
5) If Sims 3 WA will not run when sold 'as is', where the incentive to buy additional expansion packs?
Sorry, it just seems that such questions loom large over the future of Sims 3.
Obviously if most users could say with absolute certainty that....
a) Their computers are healthy
b) Their computers meet or exceed all minimum specs, and
c) they have not introduced variables such as third party hack/mods or CC
and the game still didn't load or run properly...
then yes I would say that it is a pretty safe bet that the franchise would be doomed to fail sooner rather than later.
At the risk of sounding glib however if this is not the case then I as a user would probably examine the above points a bit more thoroughly.
While the instructions provided may work for "Dummies" to load the game, it should be noted that there is still a good chance that the game still will not run using the current release & patches.
Indeed I did offer that caveat in the first few lines of the disclaimer. In looking back at the responses on this thread however I'm not sure I would phrase it quite as you have here, as it apparently has helped roughly as many as it hasn't.
Sims 3 + patch 1.46 does run for most people.
Again..while it's painfully obvious that this particular release
has seen more problems than most in recent memory, in looking around the forums I see no evidence to suggest this statement is entirely true.
SNEVEDS I realize that I have probably said some things here that you most likely don't want to hear, and that some of the statements you made were probably made out of frustration....totally understandable.
From a troubleshooting perspective however it's important to put emotion and blame aside, and just look at the facts.
The fact is the game
is running for many people but obviously not for everyone.
This fact
absolutely excludes the possibility that the problem lies
strictly with the coding,
however it doesn't exclude the possibility that something relatively simple was overlooked in the QA process when assuring that the game works with as many different user configurations as possible.
In order to
reach this conclusion however it is important that as many "user" variables as possible are eliminated.
In a perfect world I
absolutely agree that the onus shouldn't be on the user to do this...however with such a
huge & complex game where the use of third party code is rampant, it is important to establish a 'ground zero' or common point of reference for proper troubleshooting.
In order to establish with absolute certainty that the problem lies on EA's end we
have to be able to say that we are playing the game exactly the way it was coded, and tested in their QA labs.
In your case SNEVEDS, if you have performed all of the steps in this guide, your computer meets or exceeds specs, and you are not using 3rd party content of any kind, the next thing I would suspect is a faulty disk, or a corrupt download.
Hope in the end you are able to get it all sorted,
Best of luck,
UZ